What is the most accurate smartwatch or fitness tracker for step counting?

Garmin currently comes out on top for step-count accuracy, with Apple close behind. The ranking draws on daily-life and walking studies covering watches, fitness trackers and rings from the major brands.

The short answer

Garmin leads for step-count accuracy

In the largest daily-life comparison, Garmin averaged about 3% high, Apple 7% high and Fitbit 15% high. Samsung places third from its strongest direct 24-hour study.

~3% high
Most accurate overall
Best result in the pooled daily-life research.
7 studies · Garmin Vivoactive 4S, Garmin Vivoactive 4, Garmin Vivofit 3, Garmin Vivosmart HR +2 more
~7% high
Close second
Strong daily-life results, including Apple Watch Series 6.
5 studies · Apple Watch Series 6, Apple Watch Series 8, Apple Watch Series 5
10.5% error
Third
Galaxy Watch 4 performed well in a 24-hour validation study.
2 studies · Samsung Galaxy Watch 4, Samsung Gear 2
#4
~15% high
Tends to overcount
Lots of research, but daily totals often run high.
8 studies · Fitbit Inspire 2, Fitbit Charge 5, Fitbit Sense, Fitbit Sense 2 +2 more

Other brands tested

Mixed by generation
Gen 3 counted 6.2% low in one daily-life study; Gen 2 overcounted by roughly 1,400 to 2,100 steps a day.
4 studies · Oura Ring Gen 3, Oura Ring Gen 2
Strong walking results
Mi Band 2, 3 and 4 showed small errors in structured outdoor walking tests.
2 studies · Xiaomi Mi Band 2 / 3 / 4, Xiaomi Mi Band 2
Weaker overall
Polar has useful step research, but its free-living and structured results are less convincing than the leaders.
2 studies · Polar Vantage, Polar A360

What the research shows

Daily life
Garmin +3%, Apple +7%, Fitbit +15%. Those are the pooled results across 59 validation studies and form the backbone of the ranking. Read the study.
Same-day test
Apple Watch Series 6 beat Galaxy Watch 4. Apple recorded 6.4% typical error versus 10.5% for Samsung over 24 hours in the same 104-person study.
Walking tests
Garmin, Fitbit and Xiaomi can all be very close during normal walking. Garmin Vivosmart HR+ ranged from 0.56% to 2.47% error, Fitbit Inspire 2 was about 3.56%, and Xiaomi Mi Band models also performed strongly in structured walking.

Supporting studies

GarminGarmin Vivoactive 4S, Garmin Vivoactive 4, Garmin Vivofit 3, Garmin Vivosmart HR, Garmin Vivosmart HR+ +1 more7

Garmin leads the pooled daily-life comparison. Several Garmin walking studies also report low error, especially at normal walking speeds.

AppleApple Watch Series 6, Apple Watch Series 8, Apple Watch Series 55

Apple sits close behind Garmin. Apple Watch Series 6 did particularly well in daily-life testing, while slow and shuffling gait remains harder.

SamsungSamsung Galaxy Watch 4, Samsung Gear 22

Samsung has fewer step studies, but Galaxy Watch 4 produced a solid result over a full 24 hours and finished behind Apple in the same study.

FitbitFitbit Inspire 2, Fitbit Charge 5, Fitbit Sense, Fitbit Sense 2, Fitbit Charge 4 +1 more8

Fitbit has plenty of step-count research. The recurring pattern is good performance in structured walking but higher totals in daily life.

OuraOura Ring Gen 3, Oura Ring Gen 24

Oura changes substantially by generation. Gen 3 counted slightly low in one study, while Gen 2 overcounted by more than a thousand steps a day.

XiaomiXiaomi Mi Band 2 / 3 / 4, Xiaomi Mi Band 22

Xiaomi looks good in the structured walking studies in the database, particularly the Mi Band 2, 3 and 4.

PolarPolar Vantage, Polar A3602

Polar step results are mixed. The A360 struggled in structured testing and the Vantage line showed sizeable differences from research monitors in daily life.