Fitbit Charge 3 or Charge 2: should you upgrade?

Fitbit has made Charge 3 official earlier this month. The device is pretty much a smartwatch disguised as a fitness tracker. It comes as an upgrade to the Charge 2, the most popular fitness wearable on the globe since its launch some two years ago. But lets face it, while the fitness band is still a best seller it was ripe for an update.

Essential reading: Choosing the right Fitbit tracker

The San Francisco outfit is known for coming up with products for everyday users who want to get fitter and see how they are doing in real time on the wristband and also via the excellent free app and graphics-heavy desktop dashboard. The Charge series definitely serves this purpose. Its no wonder Fitbit devices have become the wearable of choice for many.

But do the differences between Charge 3 and Charge 2 mean its time for an upgrade? Read on to find out.

fitbit charge 3 or charge 2 should you upgrade 1 - Fitbit Charge 3 or Charge 2: should you upgrade? Fitbit Charge 3 or Charge 2: Design

When it comes to fitness trackers, Fitbit has not strayed very much from its signature look over the years. You can definitely recognise Charge 3 as your typical Fitbit wearable. At first glance, not all too different from its predecessor.

But look closely and you’ll notice some important design changes. The most obvious is the bigger OLED display. In fact, its 40% larger on Charge 3. Furthermore, the backlit screen is fully responsive to touch, it supports gray-scale colours, and benefits from a resolution boost.

The display on Charge 3 automatically adjusts to changes in lighting conditions so you can easily view your stats at any time, indoors or out. Swipe up to access the dashboard and in other directions to access other functionality. This is also Fitbit’s first wearable with an inductive physical button.

Finally, Charge 3 is built of more lightweight material than its predecessor. This includes an aerospace grade aluminum case and Corning Gorilla Glass 3 display. Its thinner, too, so looks less chunky on your wrist.

fitbit charge 3 or versa which is right for you 3 - Fitbit Charge 3 or Charge 2: should you upgrade?
Image source: Fitbit

Launched in 2016, the Charge 2 has become perhaps the most recognised fitness tracker in the world. It comes with a single physical button on the right which you can use, along with tapping on the B&W display, to cycle through the stats. You will be much more dependent on that physical button that on Charge 3.

Straps carry standard watch-style clasp mechanisms and are interchangeable, so you can tailor the wearable to your liking. There are three different sizes to choose from. Charge 3, on the other hand, is a one-size fits all affair.  In the box it comes with a large and small strap which you can use depending on your wrist-size.

fitbit charge 3 or charge 2 should you upgrade 2 - Fitbit Charge 3 or Charge 2: should you upgrade?
Image source: Fitbit

Under the hood, there is very little to separate the two. Both come with an optical heart rate sensor, 3-axis accelerometer, altimeter and vibration motor. Fitbit says the heart rate sensor on Charge 3 has benefitted from design improvements and will offer better accuracy during exercise.

Charge 3 also comes with a relative SpO2 sensor. This measures blood oxygen levels and could be used to identify sleep apnea and other medical conditions in the future. This is the same sensor you’ll find on Ionic and Versa, but we have yet to see it put to real-world use.

Fitbit Charge 3 or Charge 2: Battery life and water resistance

Battery life is always a compromise between size, screen resolution and more. Fitbit knows this is an important selling point when it comes to something that keeps tabs on your fitness around the clock.

Both of these devices have a rechargeable Lithium battery with decent battery life. Charge 3 will keep going for around 7 days, which is two more than its predecessor. Not a huge difference but a healthy upgrade nevertheless.

fitbit charge 2 essential information - Fitbit Charge 3 or Charge 2: should you upgrade?
Fitbit Charge 2
Gadgets & Wearables may get a commission
review qlipp tennis sensor 8 - Fitbit Charge 3 or Charge 2: should you upgrade?

The bigger difference is in water resistance. Charge 3 has a water-resistance rating of 5 ATM which means you can dunk it down to depths of 50 metres. It will track your swim sessions, too. Charge 2 is only sweat, rain and splash proof so don’t even think about submerging it under water.

fitbit charge 3 or charge 2 should you upgrade - Fitbit Charge 3 or Charge 2: should you upgrade?
Image source: Fitbit

Fitbit Charge 3 or Charge 2: Features

Both of these devices are quite good when it comes to 24/7 activity tracking. That’s what Fitbit is known for. They’ll keep tabs on your steps, distance travelled, floors climbed, active minutes, calories burned, sleep and heart rate (including current, resting and heart rate zone information).

The trackers spit out motivational messages through the day and nudge you with move reminders if you’re having a particularly lazy day. There is also automatic activity recognition which means you will get credit even if you forget to log a workout.

Finally, you’ll also get some more advanced metrics such as VO2 Max. Measured in millilitres of oxygen processed per kilogram of body weight every minute, the metric tells you how well your body uses oxygen when you’re working out at your hardest, i.e. how fit you are. And let’s not forget Breathing Sessions to keep you stress free.

fitbit charge 3 or charge 2 should you upgrade 3 - Fitbit Charge 3 or Charge 2: should you upgrade?
Image source: Fitbit

There are some subtle differences, though. The most obvious one is that the larger screen real-estate on Charge 3 means its easier to read everything, particularly during workouts.

The other difference is the above-mentioned design upgrade to the heart rate sensor. While Charge 2 is good at estimating resting heart rate, at high intensity activities accuracy tends to suffer. This should not be as much of a problem on Charge 3. Fitbit says the tracker provides a better measure of calorie burn and resting heart rate, too.

Charge 3 also comes with an auto-stop feature for runners. This automatically pauses the exercise mode if, for example, you need to stop for a traffic light or tie your shoe-lace. You can also now do more direct from the device screen such as setting goals without heading to the app.

Its worth pointing out, neither of these devices has built-GPS. If you need this, look elsewhere. The company has presumably done this to keep the cost low and battery life high. The Connected GPS means Charge 2 & 3 tap into your smartphone for a satellite reading.

Finally, lets not forget the Female Health Tracking functionality. Just like some other devices in Fitbit’s lineup, the feature is accessible on Charge 3.

While there is little to separate the two in terms of fitness tracking, the bigger difference is in the smart features. Charge 3 is essentially a smartwatch disguised as a fitness tracker.

While both devices show basic notifications, Charge 3 comes with the ability to reply to messages (for Android users) and the option to accept or reject calls. It also comes in a slightly more expensive Special Edition version, that has an NFC chip for contactless payments.

Much like the Versa and Ionic, Charge 3 also comes with apps. This includes Alarms, Timer, Weather, Calendar, Fitbit Leaderboard, as well as popular third-party apps that will be added in the coming months. Unfortunately offline storage for music or a way to control your smartphone music remotely from your wrist in not available on Charge devices.

fitbit charge 3 or charge 2 should you upgrade 1 - Fitbit Charge 3 or Charge 2: should you upgrade?
Image source: Fitbit

Fitbit Charge 3 or Charge 2: The bottom line

When it comes to fitness, Charge 3 and Charge 2 are similar animals. The main difference is that Charge 3 sports a slightly more accurate heart rate monitor and comes with an SpO2 sensor which Fitbit will, hopefully, put to actual real-world use in the near future.

The bigger differences are in terms of design and smart functionality. Charge 3 sports a 40% larger screen which is fully responsive to touch. It also comes in a water-resistant wrapping and will track your swim sessions. With a plethora of apps, NFC for payments (for the Special Edition), Quick Replies and more, the device is starting to blend the line between fitness trackers and smartwatches.

fitbit charge 3 or versa which is right for you - Fitbit Charge 3 or Charge 2: should you upgrade?
Fitbit Charge 3
Gadgets & Wearables may get a commission
review qlipp tennis sensor 8 - Fitbit Charge 3 or Charge 2: should you upgrade?

So do these upgrades mean you should shell out for a new fitness tracker?

Well, it really depends. If you own a Charge 2 and do not need waterproofing, NFC for payments and are happy with the small screen – it doesn’t make too much sense to upgrade. After all, Charge 2 remains a decent device. If on the other hand you are a first time buyer, need the new features and don’t mind a price difference, Charge 3 is the way to go.

Compare technical specs

Like this article? Subscribe to our monthly newsletter and never miss out!

23 thoughts on “Fitbit Charge 3 or Charge 2: should you upgrade?

  • Thank you for the comparison. My two biggest questions however were unasked/answered:
    (1) Will “2” bands fit the “3”? (I have an aftermarket band I adore and this is important to me.)
    (2) Is the new “crystal” more scratch and crack resistant than that of the “2”? (My “2” is cracked due to a kettle bell.)

    • The Charge 2 bands will not work with the Charge 3, totally different design. The screen on the Charge 2 is plastic. The Screen on the Charge 3 is actually Gorilla Glass 3, huge upgrade for scratch resistance.

    • Bands are not the same

  • Thank you for the article.
    I wear my Charge 2 under my work shirt and suit.
    It’s a little clunky and even a fraction of a difference in the thickness of the device would make a huge difference – do you know yet what the device thickness is between Charge 2 and Charge 3?

    • Fitbit only said its slightly thinner. Couldn’t find exactly by how much – probably just a few millimetres.

  • Sticking with the charge 2 until they release an accurate tracker for steps that counts them when pushing a stroller or a cart.

    • you should look into fitbit inspiration hr

  • Hi how about the vibration motor in 3? I can’t really feel the 2 compared to the 1.

  • Does anyone know if the 3 still has the burning problem? My 2 burns my wrist!

  • I received a fit bit last Christmas and I miss placed the charger. I think I have a Fitbit three unless you changed the number since last Christmas. I’m trying to figure out which charger to order online. Please help.

    • If you received it last Christmas it is not Charge 3 – this was released two months ago. So its either Charge 2 or one of the earlier versions. Just Google it and compare what it looks like to the pictures online.

  • I think you mean larger in this statement:
    There are some subtle differences, though. The most obvious one is that the –> smaller<– screen real-estate on Charge 3 means its easier to read everything, particularly during workouts.

    • Thanks – correction made!

  • What’s the lifespan of the Charge 3 vs the Charge 2? I bought my Charge 2 just under a year ago. Wondering if I should buy the 3 now (as “insurance”) with all the holiday sales so I’m prepared if the 2 decides to give up the ghost soon. Do you know anything about any built-in obsolescence with the 2? (battery life, etc.) Mine is still working fine though I have started experiencing more frequent sync problems so that I have to restart it more often than I used do. Thanks for any insight you may have!

    • A year is not a long time to own a fitness tracker. Lifespan? No company will list the lifespan of its fitness tracker or smartwatch. That’s because it’s impossible to say. Any decent wearable should last a few years. By that time it will pretty much become outdated – new, better devices coming out, etc.

  • I purchased the Fitbit 2 last year. Loved it. Especially getting text messages. This year I got hearing aides which are connected to Bluetooth. Now I cannot get any notification on my Fitbit. Can I with Fitbit 3?

    • Don’t see why they would interfere with notifications. Multiple bluetooth connections do not typically conflict with each other. Best off asking Fitbit support directly.

  • Fitbits aren’t worth the money. I love mine but have to get several replacements. I’ve had the hr and now Charge 2. I wonder have they improved the lifespan. I have had my Polar watch for 2 years now, no replacements ans still working fine.

  • Does the Charge 3 track when on a treadmill?

    • Yes

  • My 1st Charge 2 lasted less than a year and was replaced for free by Fitbit; that one is now about 2 years old and still doing just fine. However, I’m going to ask for a charge 3 for Christmas just because of its substantial improvements. Right now I especially love the vibrating alarm, which wakes me in the morning without waking my wife. My overall experience with Fitbit has been very positive. I honestly have no interest in a so called smart watch because they are fundamentally really just status symbols.

  • the fit bit 3 is the worst product i have every bought , i got my husband one. We have had it replace 3 time , it will not keep the correct time not unless you put it on the charger, and by the end of the day the time is off again. we have called in to customer service and all they can do is keep you on the for about a hour by the end of the call tell you they will send a replacement. my husband got me the fit bit 2 no problem at all..


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.