Review Healbe GoBe 2: can this wearable really count calories consumed?
Healbe GoBe is most people’s favorite controversial wearable. The promise is enticing. “Tell it nothing, track everything”. That is the Holy Grail of health and fitness monitoring.
I have to admit, GoBe was one of the first devices that really got me interested in fitness trackers. It appeared on Indiegogo back in 2014 as the only wearable that automatically measures the calories you consume and burn. It sounded too good to be true.
The device captured the public’s imagination and managed to raise more than $1 million dollars via the crowdfunding platform. Some thought it was a scam, some disputed the technology, some asked for their money back but to Healbe’s credit the Russian outfit did deliver a product.
Fast forward three years and Healbe is back with a new and improved GoBe. Just like the first generation, GoBe 2 monitors your calorie intake and hydration along with some basic fitness stats. Unlike the earlier generation, you don’t need to let the wearable know when you have eaten. That is the claim, at least. Everything is tracked automatically for you. It also comes with design improvements and some additional sensors.
Essential reading: Top fitness trackers and health gadgets
Fitness trackers are a dime a dozen these days but they pretty much track the same things. Healbe’s competitors can only count steps and measure heart rate, but none of them can count calories or assess hydration levels.
Imagine never having to manually log your calorie intake, the device on your wrist does it all for you. A game changer, if it works. And that’s what I set out to determine by wearing this unusual fitness band for a month.
In the box, GoBe 2 arrives with the fitness band, charging dock, charging cable and little instruction booklet. While slightly more elegant than the original, the wearable and its flexible and adjustable wristband is still rather retro-looking.
Measuring some 5.8cm across and 3.8cm wide, GoBe is very noticeable. Some would say (at about 1.6cm in thickness) it is huge. Onlookers definitely won’t mistake it for a watch so you are bound to answer some questions from curious bystanders. I wore it on my right wrist, so as to compare its results with my Forerunner 935 smartwatch which I simultaneously wore on my left.
The device is definitely not going to win any awards in the looks department. I opted to wear it under my sleeve – luckily the weather was cold! Having said that, I did find the tracker comfortable to wear as it is very light thanks to its plastic casing.
The top of GoBe is a bright blue dot-matrix display. Off by default to conserve battery, it springs to life when you press the physical button on the right. Repeatedly pressing the button cycles through time, battery level, current heart rate, calorie balance, steps, hydration and more. The screen is not easy to read and for the most part I found myself referring to the app when I wanted to review daily stats. There is also web dashboard for a more detailed overview. Both the app and website dashboard do a great job in reporting your vitals.
In order to ensure correct readings, the gold sensor on the underside of the tracker needs to be in snug contact with your skin. If there is a problem GoBe will alert you by vibrating and showing NO CONTACT on the display. You can also use the app to check whether you are wearing it correctly.
Under the hood, you won’t find the typical list of sensors. Instead, the wearable houses an accelerometer for measuring body movement and activity; a Piezo pressure sensor for measuring blood flow and heart rate; and an impendance sensor which uses different frequencies to measure fluid levels in tissues. There is also a galvanic skin response sensor for measuring stress, a gyroscope and a magnetometer.
I’ll try to keep the science lesson short. When it comes to the calorie-tracking bit, the most important of the lot is the bio-impendance sensor. GoBe 2 combines its readings with patented FLOW Technology to analyze changes in your body’s glucose concentration. As glucose concentrations rise, cells absorb glucose and release water. The impedance sensor sends high and low-frequency signals through your tissue to measure the fluid moving in and out of your cells. The system then applies some fancy algorithms to analyze this data and determine the calorie intake. That’s the theory according to GoBe.
Non-invasive glucose monitoring is the dream for most diabetics patients. Many companies have spent years trying to crack the problem with no real-world success. Apple is said to be working on a solution but sources close to the project say it is still years off from making it into a commercial product. The Cupertino outfit has even hired a team of around 200 PhDs as part of its effort on this front.
The obvious question is why Healbe simply doesn’t sell this technology. Something that automatically tracks calories should make them rich beyond their wildest dreams.
The company says this is because GoBe is not intended for medical use and it doesn’t meet medical accuracy requirements. This is also why the device does not display glucose concentrations to the user. But that GoBe’s accuracy is quite enough for assessing calorie intake.
When it comes to battery life, you will need to get used to charging it on a daily basis. I would typically throw it on the charger for an hour or so during the day to keep it topped up. On a full charge it will keep going up to 48 hours. You’ll need to put some thought into when you want to charge so you don’t miss tracking any important data. The dock uses magnets to attach to the bottom of the unit. The light on the back of the the charger goes from blue to red to indicate it is working and the tracker will vibrate when fully charged.
When you put it back on your wrist, you will need to remember to press the power button. Otherwise your GoBe will not track anything. More than once I’ve made the mistake of walking around for a few hours, not realizing it wasn’t recording any data.
This is a wearable that does all the normal things that most fitness trackers do such as keeping count of the number of steps and distance covered, heart rate, calories burned and sleep quality. But GoBe 2 tries to go further in the sense that it displays a value for calories digested, hydration balance and emotional state. Previously, there was even an experimental blood pressure reading feature which was subsequently removed.
After taking the device out of the box and charging it, you’ll need to downloaded the iOS or Android app and add in your personal information such as weight and height. Keep in mind that it takes up to two weeks of wearing the tracker at least 12-18 hours per day for GoBe to collect enough information to get maximum accuracy. You will get readings right from the get-go, but these may be skewed. Hence, I pretty much ignored the data for the first couple of weeks and paid much closer attention in the period after.
As mentioned, your current daily stats can be viewed on the device itself. However, you’ll probably find yourself referring to the app much more often as it shows off your vital statistics much more elegantly and with additional detail. In the end I only used the dot matrix display to check on the battery level.
The tabs along the bottom of the smartphone app allow you to switch between the daily overview, weight (which can be downloaded automatically by linking to a third party source), device status page and user profile. The daily overview is divided into five subsections: Energy Balance, Hydration Level, Heart Rate, Sleep and Stress Level. Tapping on each of these takes you through to a new screen with much more information.
Healbe says the calorie tracking feature is the most misunderstood point it gets from its customer support line. The GoBe2 tracks only digested calories, not consumed. This can’t be overemphasized enough as there is an important difference between the two.
Food takes anywhere up to 72 hours to move through your digestive tract. The exact time depends on the amounts and types of foods you’ve eaten. The rate is also based on factors such as your gender, metabolism, and whether you have any digestive issues that slow down or speed up the process. The quickest foods to digest are processed, sugary junk foods such as candy bars. Your body tears through them in a matter of hours, quickly leaving you hungry again.
The Energy Balance screen combines activity tracking and calorie monitoring to provide you with a single figure showing whether you have burned more calories than you have digested on a particular day. To arrive at the calculation, the app tallies up your calories digested and subtracts your basal metabolic rate and calories burned through activity. The result will be a plus or minus figure. Plus means you are gaining weight, minus means you are losing weight. You’ll also get an estimate of the intake of nutrients, i.e. how much of the intake was fat, carbohydrates and protein.
Along the top is a continuous graph which does a nice job of showing your metabolic processes. This also takes into account other factors, as metabolic processes depend not only on the food consumed but also physical activity, stress, sleep and more.
To arrive at estimates of calories absorbed GoBe looks at glucose concentrations in your cells. When you digest food your cells absorb glucose and release water. Fat and protein in your food influence the rate of glucose absorption—leading to different shapes and durations of the “glucose curve”. The device uses the impedance sensor to measure the fluid moving in and out of your cells—continuously, around the clock.
The million dollar question, of course, is whether GoBe2 can really figure out what and how much you’ve eaten?
Well… I was not convinced.
I started off by writing the number of calories consumed on a daily basis but quickly came to the conclusion this was a futile task. The main difficulty is the above stated fact that it can take up to 3 days for the food that is consumed to be digested. So even if you try to do a fasting experiment, GoBe may show a calorie intake as the body is still operating in all functions using internal resources. And even for the sake of this review, I didn’t particularly want to go without eating for more than 3 days! It would be an interesting experiment though…
Carl Sagan popularized the term “Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence”. This later came to be known as the Sagan standard. Healbe does provide evidence, but I’m not sure it equates to “extraordinary evidence”. It cites a third-party test which was done by the Saint Petersburg State Institute of Health, Medical and Sports Clinic, a leading institution in the field of sports medicine in St. Petersburg, Russia.
To cut a long story short, a total of 44 tests were conducted on five individuals over a period of 5 days. Researchers of the Russian university found that GoBe measured calorie intake to within +/- 15.6% and calorie burn to within +/- 6.6%.
I do not hold any scientific degrees, so cannot vouch whether it is possible to track calories digested by measuring the fluid moving in and out of cells. But adding some more credence to the technology is the fact that Healbe has recently signed a five-year agreement with The University of California, Davis (UC Davis), Foods for Health Institute. The research will aim to determine whether advanced personal fitness trackers can be used to help bring precision-based health solutions to consumers. I will be following the research findings with keen interest.
In my personal opinion, it seemed like the wearable was spitting out random numbers as far as the calories burned. I did not find much use for the figures as I didn’t trust them.
I was also very curious about the hydration features of this fitness tracker. No other fitness tracker or smartwatch estimates your fluid intake. The crowdfunded LVL has been delayed by a year and we were promised a summer 2018 launch. After a few updates, its backers have now been hit with a wall of silence.
But back to GoBe 2. Similar to the calorie consumption, you can monitor your hydration balance continuously on a graph. Ultimately the device became obsessed with getting me to drink more water! Multiple times per day the fitness tracker would nag me to take in some more liquid. This can only be a good thing as I am the first to admit I do not drink enough water. On the flip side, its showed that my hydration was low 99% of the time – which I find hard to believe. Nevertheless, its provides a good reminder to drink.
Stress monitoring is becoming more and more common. Most Garmin devices now tap into heart-rate variability readings to calculate and measure stress levels. This is done 24/7 so you have a timeline of your stress readings available in the smartphone app. GoBe 2 tracks stress through the moisture in your skin. The amount of moisture determines the degree of stress. The tracker does a pretty decent job on this count and flags up calm periods, low and moderate stress and emotional tension.
Apart from these metrics the wearable also dishes out your daily heart rate. It does a good job for your resting heart rate and low intensity activities, but like many other fitness trackers the accuracy does deteriorate at high intensity activity. GoBe also does a decent job in tracking your sleep, even if it under-reported my sleep duration as compared to the Forerunner 935. You’ll get info on sleep duration, the number of times you woke up and a percentage score for your sleep quality and efficiency.
Finally, there is also nifty web dashboard which shows your daily stats in great detail. You can also opt into a weekly email showing your progress over the past 7 days.
I was hoping for a lot from GoBe 2, but at the same time not really expecting that much. In the end I was left disappointed and not at all convinced their technology works.
To start off, the device would definitely benefit from a design overhaul. Wearing it under my sleeve was not a problem. But it would be something I would be embarrassed to wear with a short sleeved shirt.
If you’ve ever tracked your calories with apps like My Fitness Pal you know how much of a hassle this can be. Most people give up after a few days or weeks. I attempted to do it, but gave up pretty much the same day.
GoBe 2 is an attempt at a wearable that does this job for you. As I found, not a very good one. I did not trust the figures it was dishing out, and due to the way they were calculated (with a time gap), there is no way to prove or disprove the technology works.
Other than that you get the usual fitness tracking statistics. The same statistics you’d get with any other wearable, including devices that are many times cheaper. For the price of a GoBe you could even buy yourself a decent sports watch from a well known brand – which in my experience would be a much wiser investment.
We are a review site that receives a small commission from sales of certain items, but the price is the same for you. Purchasing items by clicking on links in this article allows us to run this website. We are independently owned and all opinions expressed here are our own. See our affiliate disclosure page for more details.
Like this article? Subscribe to our monthly newsletter and never miss out.
4 thoughts on “Review Healbe GoBe 2: can this wearable really count calories consumed?”
Very great review! Very helpful, thank you.
The article, which you write about (…”read the full findings on this link”) is not available. Can you please send it to me? 🙂
Thank you in advance,
Hi – it seems Healbe has removed the PDF from their website. You might want to speak to them to obtain a copy.
Here are the links to the recent validation studies at UC Davis.
Calorie intake validation report – http://bit.ly/ucdavis_validation
Hydration feature report – http://bit.ly/ucdavis_validation_hydration